As the investigation into the mysterious church fire continues, Jack is forced to question Cat about the burnt whale oil can he found in her shed. Cat explains that she uses the oil for her candle business and assures Jack had nothing to do with the church fire. While Jack believes her, all the evidence points to her, including the fact that Cat was one of the only townspeople not at the vigil for the fallen miners on the night of the fire.
In an effort to clear Cat’s name, Jack decides to interview Cat’s children. Cat’s son Gabe says he doesn’t know where his mother was the night of the fire and that she didn’t come home until very late that evening. Next, Jack interviews Cat’s daughter Emily who says her mother actually got home the following morning. With an obvious inconsistency in their stories, Jack interviews Cat again but she refuses to explain herself leaving Jack no choice but to arrest her.
Meanwhile, at school, Elizabeth is given a very expensive necklace by one of her students. Nicknamed "Pockets,"Albert is a shy boy who has a peculiar habit of collecting odd items and storing them in his trouser pockets. Albert explains that he found the necklace in a nearby creek and that it actually belongs to James Spurlock. Elizabeth is very grateful for the gift, but explains to Albert that she can’t accept it. She goes on to say that women appreciate gifts from the heart over gifts that are solely based on money. Elizabeth gives Albert a kiss and tells him he’ll make a lucky girl very happy one day.