As Kevin remains missing, Mick, Nell and the rest of the O'Brien family nervously wait for more news, while Abby goes to New York to fight for custody of her daughters.
Cassie is about to close up the store for the evening when Martha comes in looking for a map of historic Middleton. Once she finds the map, Martha realizes it might be a bit older than what she was looking for. Sam surprises Cassie by bringing in boxes for her to help pack old inventory to make room for new arrivals. When Sam kisses Cassie before departing, Martha points out to Cassie that it definitely appears she and Sam have gotten closer.
The stars of "Cooking with Love," Ali Liebert and Brett Dalton put their Valentine’s Day knowledge to the test in the speed round of Hallmark Channel’s X’s & O’s Challenge.
Sam and Cassie eat cake as they enjoy their honeymoon at the winery. Erin, the winery’s owner, catches up with them but is surprised when her brother shows up unexpectedly with the news that the vineyard may be closing. At home, Grace talks to Vincent about Noah and their long-distance relationship. Grace then receives a call from Noah, telling her he wants to break up. She then opens up to Abigail about the breakup. Martha auditions for the talk show, but when it's her turn in front of the camera, she freezes on air.
