Abigail visits Donovan at the office with a toy for his dog. The two kiss but are surprised when his mom interrupts them. She invites them both to dinner. Donovan warns Abigail that his mother always has a hidden agenda and that it’s "never just dinner.”
Stephanie unexpectantly meets Melanie, Adam’s fiancé, at the Bistro. As Cassie welcomes her guests, Sam is surprised to see Martha and her husband Tom checking in for a Grey-Cation. Jacob, Nick’s friend is injured in his hockey game and won’t be able to play for at least six months, putting his college scholarship in jeopardy.
Sam and Cassie meet Luke when he comes by to pick up Grace for a date. Sam interrogates him and tells him that he expects him to be a gentleman. While on their roller-skating date, Luke receives a call and ominously says to the caller on the other end that he still hasn’t found out anything from Grace. Later on in the date, Luke tries to open up to Grace but changes his mind and invites her to skate some more. On the rink, the two share their first kiss.
Stephanie visits Adam at the hospital and asks about Melanie. Adam is confused. He had no idea Melanie was in town and that she is referring to herself as his current fiancé. After a meeting with a patient, Melanie finds Adam. The two sit down to talk. Melanie tells Adam that she misses him and wants a second chance.
Martha and Tom challenge Sam and Cassie to a card game called Spouse Trap. They beat Sam and Cassie who can’t seem to get one correct answer.
Abigail attends dinner at Donovan’s parents’ house. At first, Abigail bonds with Donovan's mother but later at dinner, Donovan's mother expresses concern over Abigail and Donovan's relationship. She even goes so far as to encourage them to break up because the two families are possibly cursed. The two leave abruptly. Donovan tries to calm Abigail's concerns about the curse but they both become alarmed when a painting on the wall suddenly falls to floor.
Sam stops by to see Jacob and introduce himself to a specialist, a former pro hockey player who had a serious injury that he recovered from. He gives hope to Jacob that he too can recover and go back to playing hockey. Adam visits Stephanie at the bistro and tells her that all he thinks about is her and the two kiss.