Cassie and Sam clean up a storage room as they prepare to have Nick move in. Sam expressed how he doesn’t think Nick is taking his future, post high school, seriously. Cassie encourages him to give it time and it will all work out. The two get excited as their wedding is only two days away. Cassie comes across an old folder with a wedding photo of her great great great grandmother and her husband Douglas on their wedding day. Cassie reminisces on the history around the photo which was taken in front of a forever tree. Cassie tells Sam the tree is a sign of good luck for a lifetime of happiness.
Stephanie, Abigail and Martha set up for the wedding. While looking for a ladder at the wedding site, Nick meets Lindsey in the horse stables and is rendered speechless. The two bond over their love for the game Destination. She shows him a new horse that they haven’t been able to break in.
Vincent, Cassie’s foster brother, surprises her at the house. He arrives with gifts for everyone and Cassie and Grace are thrilled that he will be attending the wedding. Cassie and Vincent reminisce about the old days growing up together. Privately Sam urges Cassie to be careful, he would hate to see her disappointed or hurt again with Vincent around. In addition to Vincent, Sam’s mother and father arrive for the wedding as well.
Stephanie visiting the hospital to see a customer meets the hospital Chaplin, Adam and is intrigued by him. Sam shares with his dad, as they get fitted for suits, that he wants to look for the forever. Nick gets dating advice from his grandfather. Meanwhile, Grace tries on her bridesmaids dress and expresses concern to Abigail that a lot of things are going wrong with the wedding preparations.
Over at the store, Martha tries to guess what customers need, Stephanie stops in and Martha tries to make a special blend to help her headache, unable to make it, she provides aspirin instead. Stephanie asks about Adam. Martha implies that Adam is a bit out of her league.
Sam continues his search for the forever tree. Sam’s mom reminisces about the old times when she was just married. She passes along advice to Cassie and Sam and encourages them to never stop doing the little things.
Over coffee, Grace asks Vincent if he remembers her dad. Adam swings by and surprises Stephanie at the bistro asking for orange juice for his baseball team.
Cassie and Sam drink tea and get excited for tomorrow’s wedding. Sam discovers a 100-year-old map that might show where they can find the forever tree. Vincent joins them in their quest to track it down, giving Vincent and Sam a chance to bond.
Nick starts to work on his college applications in hopes of impressing Lindsey. He goes to visit her again and asks her out for dessert at the bistro. Abigail and Cassie catch up over a piece of chocolate cake. Martha, now working in Abigail's flower shop, seems to have more success dishing out advice, over making sales.
Sam walks in on Vincent on a tense call and becomes concerned. Abigail meets the mayor of Davenport she asks him to restore town lines so that Martha can be a resident of Middleton. The two instantly clash. Cassie’s gown arrives and the gown is ruined having been eaten by moths.