The town gathers at the observatory to view the comet and to make a wish. While there, Sam realizes the key that Martha found in the town’s charter is the key to the next clue. It leads them to the meeting house which unfortunately was demolished years ago, so the mystery continues. As Abigail is getting ready to leave for Europe, Martha asks her to stop by the town hall and sign some paperwork. When she arrives, she sees it is a set up for her to talk to Donovan. Donovan shows her that he doesn’t believe in superstitions as he opens an umbrella, walks under a ladder and breaks a mirror. Donovan asks for another chance and Abigail agrees to try it again, bad luck and all.