Episode 6: The Festive Five
Five leading men face an emotional acting scene with Rachel Boston, directed by Ali Liebert. Contestants must draw on events from their past to help them make the sad scene believable. With Jonathan Bennett and Melissa Peterman.
Episode 5: Laughing All the Way
The remaining men decide if they want to bring someone back. A festive faceoff squeezes every ounce of energy out of the guys, they try improv with some special scene partners - B.J. Britt, Jonathan Bennett and Melissa Peterman.
Episode 4: The Talented Mr. Christmas
The remaining men tackle an outdoor holiday-themed obstacle course, then show their stuff in a Mr. Christmas talent show. And, a backstage surprise with Keltie Knight from E! News. With Jonathan Bennett and Melissa Peterman.
Episode 3: Falling for You
After battling tangled Christmas lights, the contestants learn their next scene partner is Hallmark's Brooke D'Orsay. Not only must they learn their lines, but they've got to act on ice! With Jonathan Bennett and Melissa Peterman.
Episode 2: Mr. December
Nine unknown talents compete in a Mr. December photoshoot where fan fav Tyler Hynes helps them navigate celebrity photographers, Hallmark Superfans, and demanding co-stars. With Jonathan Bennett, Melissa Peterman and Tyler Hynes.
Episode 1: The Hunt for Mr. Christmas
Ten unknown talents compete for the role of a lifetime—a leading role in a Hallmark Christmas movie. Host Jonathan Bennett invites Erin Cahill to be their first scene partner. With Jonathan Bennett, Melissa Peterman and Erin Cahill.